Most organisations begin with a spark. Someone has a vision, gathers a few people around them, and starts something. There’s energy in the room. People care about why they’re there. The early days of any worthwhile organisation, a charity, a business, a church, a movement, tend to look and feel similar. The harder question is whether what gets started can outlast the people who started it.
Founders give an organisation its initial shape. Their passion, their charisma, their convictions, all of it imprints onto the early days. But organisations that depend entirely on their founders rarely survive them. The ones that endure have done the harder work of becoming something bigger than the original cast.
That requires structure, succession, and a culture that holds when the founders aren’t in the room. It also requires an honest understanding of how organisations actually evolve over time, because the patterns are predictable, and so are the places they tend to break.
Richard Rohr’s framework
In his book The Wisdom Pattern, Richard Rohr describes a sequence of stages that religious and cultural institutions tend to move through over time. It’s a pattern that applies just as cleanly to businesses, charities, and any organisation built around a shared purpose. There are three stages a healthy organisation cycles through, and two stages that broken ones get stuck in.
1. Movement
This is the beginning. The organisation is born out of personal and communal experience. It’s driven by passion, vision, and a sense that something needs to change. There’s energy. There’s risk. There’s adaptability. It feels less like a structure and more like a family.
Movements are flexible by nature. They don’t have rigid systems because they don’t need them yet. People are bound together by purpose rather than process. Movements have a world-changing mentality, even when they’re small.
2. Machine
Eventually, growth requires structure. You can’t run a 200-person organisation the same way you ran a five-person one. Roles get formalised. Processes get documented. Hierarchies emerge. A machine begins to take shape.
The machine isn’t the enemy. Done well, it serves the movement. The trick is keeping the machine minimal, present only to enable the original purpose, not to constrain it. Organisations that strike this balance well grow and multiply while keeping community at the centre. They stay visionary while becoming organised.
3. Memory
The third stage is about wisdom. Organisations that reach maturity carry the memory of what came before, the founding stories, the hard-won lessons, the values that originally shaped them. The memory stage involves rediscovering and reconnecting with that wisdom, which leads to revitalisation rather than nostalgia.
This is where the cycle should restart. Inspired by what they remember, the organisation rediscovers its movement energy and starts the loop again. Movement, machine, memory, movement. The healthiest organisations cycle through these three stages over and over, growing and renewing themselves with each turn.
4. Monument
But not every organisation cycles back. Some get stuck.
When the machine becomes excessive and the memory becomes oppressive (revered rather than revisited), an organisation slides into the monument stage. Tradition becomes the priority. Authority gets enforced. Structure tightens. Member participation gets controlled rather than encouraged. Survival becomes the goal, replacing the original mission.
It looks impressive from the outside. Inside, the energy has gone.
5. Mausoleum
The final stage is the worst. Mausoleums are organisations that have ossified completely. The hierarchy is rigid. The roles are fixed. The history is sacred. Innovation is treated as betrayal. The leadership is top-down and the focus is preservation, not purpose.
A mausoleum can carry on for decades, sometimes centuries. The exterior can be magnificent. But there’s no real life inside, and everyone who works there knows it.
Why this matters for churches
Churches are particularly prone to this pattern. Most start as movements, with passionate founders and a clear sense of mission. Many grow into healthy machines that retain real spiritual energy. Some carry their memory well and keep cycling back into renewal.
But many drift into monument or mausoleum. Tradition becomes more important than the people. Branding gets defended above mission. The audience is managed rather than empowered. The original fire is admired in stained glass but no longer felt in the room.
The good news is that mausoleums can come back to life. Not easily, and not without disruption. Renewal usually requires reconnecting with founding vision, empowering ordinary members, embracing real change, raising up new leaders, and rekindling the community passion that once made the place alive. None of that is comfortable, but it’s possible.
Six ways to avoid getting stuck
If you lead any kind of organisation and want to keep it cycling through the healthy stages rather than drifting into the broken ones, six things help.
- Build a learning culture. Curiosity should be the default, not the exception. Make it safe for people to ask questions, challenge assumptions, and learn from mistakes. Where it isn’t safe, the truth stays underground and the organisation slowly drifts.
- Open the communication. Diverse perspectives only matter if people can actually share them. Identify what’s stopping honest dialogue across teams and departments, and remove those barriers deliberately.
- Reward experimentation, even when it fails. Growth mindsets don’t appear by accident. They get built by leaders who genuinely celebrate the attempt, not just the success. Failures that produce real learning are wins.
- Resource creativity properly. Innovation needs time, budget, and people. If you say you value it but never give it real space on the calendar or the spreadsheet, the message your team hears is the opposite of what you’re saying.
- Stay plugged in to the outside world. What’s happening with your customers, your sector, your wider context? Organisations that lose external awareness drift into monument territory faster than they realise.
- Pursue real diversity. Different backgrounds, different experiences, different ways of thinking. The fastest way to keep your organisation fresh is to make sure the people in it aren’t all looking at the world from the same angle.
A few additional questions worth turning over as a leader.
- Are we walking what we preach, or are there gaps between what we say we value and what we actually reward?
- Are our systems, processes, and incentives genuinely aligned with the values we claim?
- What signals would tell us we’re slipping into monument behaviour, and would we have the honesty to act on them?
Choosing the cycle
The pattern Rohr describes isn’t deterministic. Organisations don’t have to drift into stagnation. The ones that don’t are the ones whose leaders pay attention, ask hard questions, and keep choosing the harder, messier work of renewal over the easier comfort of preservation.
If you’re leading something, the question is which way your organisation is currently moving. Towards another cycle of movement, machine, and memory? Or quietly towards monument and mausoleum?
Most leaders don’t notice the drift until it’s well underway. Notice early. Choose the cycle deliberately.
So when you look honestly at the organisation you lead or belong to right now, which of the five stages is it actually in, and what would have to change for it to cycle back into movement?